Skip to content
AthleticPeak Pro

Language

Text size

MenuMenu
Language

Text size

Start FreeSign in
Start Free
Back to journal
Athlete Development, Training Philosophy

Why Fueling Beats a Number on the Scale

Why track athletes should fuel for power, not a lighter number on the scale.

David Brannan Published Nov 13, 2026 13 min read
Why Fueling Beats a Number on the Scale

It was 1992, an Olympic year. I had just married my wife, Tori, a certified NATA athletic trainer, and she was going to help me prepare for my run at the Olympic team.

We did everything the way it was supposed to be done. Whole foods. Lean proteins. Natural, clean, healthy eating, the kind any nutrition poster of the day would have approved of.

I walked into that year at 168 pounds and about 7% body fat. I was training three to five hours a day. Within months I was down to 157 pounds, and it wasn't a good 157. I was flat. I was losing power, and in the pole vault, power is the whole game.

The food wasn't bad. There just wasn't enough of it. Clean food is bulky and filling, and I couldn't physically eat enough of it to cover what I was burning. My body made up the difference by using muscle.

The fix surprised both of us. We added cheap, dense calories: Oreos, ice cream, richer meals. I still ate plenty of the good stuff, but now I could actually hit my energy needs. I didn't get fat. My weight came back, held steady, and so did my power.

I'm not telling this story to sell you on cookies. That was a short-term, practical solution for a very high training load, not a general recommendation. The real point is simpler: I was eating what everyone believed was the right diet, and it was wrong for my workload. That's the mistake this article is about, and I still see athletes make it today.

Power-to-weight is the number that matters

In the explosive events you're moving your own body against gravity, so the force you make only counts relative to the mass you carry. Researchers describe the target as a high proportion of lean mass, much of it skeletal muscle, with a lower proportion of fat (Pettersson et al., 2024).

The IAAF's 2019 review on sprint nutrition makes a point I wish I'd heard in 1992. The goal isn't just bigger muscles. It's explosive power, a good power-to-weight ratio and a strong anaerobic engine (Slater et al., 2019).

The ideal mix differs a little by event:

  • Sprinters can carry the most muscle, as long as it's in the legs and hips. Studies have found that the fastest sprinters tend to have the most lower-body muscle mass.
  • Jumpers tend to run lighter, and the high jump is usually the leanest of all (Killer et al., 2019).
  • Hurdlers look a lot like sprinters, with more emphasis on leg length and hip mobility.
  • Pole vaulters need more upper-body and trunk strength than other jumpers, for the swing and inversion. A somewhat heavier, stronger vaulter can also bend a stiffer pole, but runway speed still drives everything.
  • Multi-event athletes benefit from more mass. In one study of college decathletes, body mass and muscle mass both tracked closely with points scored (Aikawa et al.).

Notice what's missing from that list: "as light as possible." Light is only useful when the power stays.

Two ways to move the ratio, and the trap

A ratio has a top and a bottom. You can raise it by making more force, or by carrying less weight. On paper both work. In real life, chasing the bottom number is where athletes get hurt.

Here's an illustration using round numbers (not my actual lifts from 1992):

Scenario

Bodyweight

Back squat

Squat ÷ bodyweight

Well fueled

168 lb

400 lb

2.38×

Under-fueled, lost muscle

157 lb

350 lb

2.23×

Fueled, stronger

170 lb

425 lb

2.50×

Want to see your own numbers? Try the free Relative Strength Calculator. No account needed.

The under-fueled athlete is 11 pounds lighter and worse off. When weight comes off as muscle, strength drops faster than bodyweight, and the ratio falls. That's what happened to me.

The same logic works the other way. Gaining weight only helps if the power gained outpaces the pounds added. Sports dietitian Gary Slater and colleagues note that if power doesn't rise faster than weight, performance is unlikely to improve (Slater et al., 2019). So I'd say "chase power" rather than "chase weight" in either direction. Feed the training, build the engine, and let bodyweight settle where the athlete performs best.

What under-fueling does to an athlete

What happened to me now has a name. The International Olympic Committee calls it Relative Energy Deficiency in Sport, or REDs. It happens when an athlete doesn't eat enough to cover both training and normal body function. Its 2023 consensus statement lists common triggers in sport, including heavy training volume and attempts to improve power-to-weight ratios (Mountjoy et al., 2023). That second one describes our events exactly.

The effects reach well beyond feeling tired. The IOC describes impaired metabolic rate, menstrual function, bone health, immunity, protein synthesis and cardiovascular health (Mountjoy et al., 2018). In plain coaching terms, that means:

  • Bone stress injuries. Stress fractures in the foot, shin and lower back are the classic sign in jumpers and sprinters. One summary of the research lists a BMI under 17.5, low testosterone and losing more than 10% of bodyweight in a month as risk factors (Navarro Torres Arpi, 2023).
  • Hormone disruption. Missed or stopped periods in women, and low testosterone in men.
  • Stalled or falling performance, even when training is going well.
  • More illness, poorer sleep and low mood.

The timing makes this especially serious for young athletes. Most peak bone mass is built by about age 18, so a teenager who under-fuels through high school can carry weaker bones for life. Growth spurts already demand extra energy; restricting at the same time compounds the problem.

At the other end, carrying extra weight isn't free either. Takeoffs load the tendons with many times bodyweight, and body weight and BMI show up as possible risk factors for jumper's knee. But a systematic review found no strong evidence for any single risk factor (van der Worp et al., 2011). Training load still matters more than the scale.

What fueling for power looks like

No magic diet exists for explosive athletes. The 2019 IAAF consensus on nutrition for athletics recommends a food-first approach, personalized to the athlete and adjusted across the season (Burke et al., 2019). The research does give some useful starting points.

Energy first. The most useful concept is energy availability: the calories left over for the body after training, per kilogram of lean mass. Controlled lab studies in women found that healthy function is typically maintained at about 45 kcal per kg of lean mass per day. Many body systems are disrupted below about 30 (Mountjoy et al., 2018). The authors note those cutoffs don't predict problems in everyone, so treat them as guides, not hard lines. Targets for men are often set a little lower, around 40.

A rough way to estimate daily needs:

Daily calories ≈ (lean mass in kg × 40–45) + calories burned in training

Example athlete

Lean mass

Training burn

Estimated daily need

Female vaulter, 60 kg, about 17% fat

≈ 50 kg

≈ 450 kcal

≈ 2,700 kcal

Male sprinter, 75 kg, about 9% fat

≈ 68 kg

≈ 550 kcal

≈ 3,270 kcal

Now look at the training I was doing in 1992: three to five hours a day. My training burn alone was likely well over a thousand calories a day. No wonder chicken breast and steamed vegetables couldn't keep up.

Protein. For track and field athletes maintaining or gaining weight, the IAAF review suggests about 1.6 g per kg of bodyweight per day, and more during a deliberate cut to protect muscle (Witard et al., 2019). For jumpers, the event-specific review suggests 1.5 to 1.8 g/kg (Killer et al., 2019). Spread it across the day. The sprint review suggests meals with about 0.4 g/kg of quality protein every 3 to 5 hours (Slater et al., 2019).

Carbohydrate. Sprinters and jumpers are generally well served by about 3 to 6 g/kg per day: the higher end on heavy days, the lower end on light days. Multi-event athletes often need 5 to 8 g/kg to support multiple sessions.

Fat fills in the rest. Very low-fat diets make high calorie targets much harder to reach.

When clean eating isn't enough

Whole foods should be the base of an athlete's diet. That part of what Tori and I did was right. The problem was volume. Vegetables, fruit, lean meat and whole grains are filling for the calories they carry, which is exactly why they work so well for people trying to lose weight. An athlete in heavy training is trying to do the opposite.

At some point your stomach runs out of room before your body runs out of need. That's when calorie-dense foods earn their place. They don't have to be cookies and ice cream, though for me they were, and I'm not ashamed of it in that context. Better everyday options include:

  • Whole milk, chocolate milk, yogurt and cheese
  • Nuts, nut butters and trail mix
  • Olive oil, butter or avocado added to meals
  • Rice, pasta, bagels, granola and dried fruit
  • A real snack before bed and right after practice

A little dessert in a high-volume training block isn't a moral failure. It's fuel. What matters is that total intake matches the work, protein is spread through the day, and the base of the diet is still real food.

Some signs an athlete may simply not be eating enough: bodyweight sliding down during heavy training, lifts stalling or dropping, always feeling cold or flat, and getting sick a lot. In 1992, I had the first two.

Track the ratio, not the scale

If I could go back to 1992, I'd stop judging that season by bodyweight and start watching strength relative to bodyweight. A ratio tells you whether weight changes are helping or hurting. The scale can't.

That's why we built the free Relative Strength Calculator. Enter your bodyweight and your one-rep max for the squat, bench press, deadlift and overhead press, and it shows each lift as a multiple of bodyweight. It also gives your squat, bench and deadlift total. No account needed.

How to use it as a fueling check:

  1. Get a baseline. Test or estimate your maxes. If you don't want to test a true 1RM, use the 1RM Estimator from a recent set.
  2. Recheck every 4 to 6 weeks, at the same time of day and under similar conditions.
  3. Read the trend, not one number.
    • Bodyweight steady or up, ratio up: you're fueling the work. Keep going.
    • Bodyweight down, ratio up: the weight coming off is probably not muscle. Fine in moderation, but watch it.
    • Bodyweight down, ratio down: a red flag for under-fueling. Eat more before you train harder.
    • Bodyweight up, ratio down: the added mass isn't turning into strength yet.
  4. Pair it with event markers. Relative strength in the weight room is a proxy, not the event itself. Track a standing long jump, a countermovement jump or a fly-in 30m alongside it.

A few honest limits. A ratio isn't a percentile, and the calculator doesn't adjust for age, sex or lifting technique. If you want reference bands, the Benchmark Comparison tool is built for that. And for young athletes, rising numbers during a growth spurt are a better sign than any particular ratio.

For coaches and parents

We have real influence here, and it cuts both ways. A comment meant to help can start years of trouble, especially for a teenager in a lean event like the high jump or the vault.

What helps:

  • Talk about fuel, not weight. "Did you eat enough to train today?" is a coaching question. "You'd jump higher if you dropped a few pounds" is not.
  • Measure performance, not bodies. Jumps, sprint times, pole progressions and relative strength trends tell you what you need to know.
  • Keep body measurements private and professional. No public weigh-ins. If body composition needs checking, let a physician or registered sports dietitian handle it.
  • Make food easy. Parents can help most with logistics: breakfast, snacks in the bag, a meal soon after practice, and plenty of food during growth spurts.
  • Expect growth to disrupt things. A 15-year-old who gains weight and loses a little speed is usually growing, not getting out of shape.

When to refer: missed or irregular periods, repeated stress injuries, falling performance despite good training, frequent illness, or any sign of anxiety around food. Those call for a physician and a registered dietitian (ideally a board-certified sports dietitian, CSSD), not a pep talk. The IAAF consensus recommends exactly that kind of team approach: athlete, coach and accredited nutrition professionals working together (Burke et al., 2019).

Chase power

I didn't make the Olympic team in 1992, and I won't pretend a few months of under-eating was the only reason. But I know I gave away power I had earned, in the year I needed it most, by doing what everyone thought was right.

If you take one thing from this: train for power, eat for the training, and judge your body by what it can do. Use the Relative Strength Calculator to keep yourself honest, and let the scale be a footnote.

Train with purpose.


This article is general education from a coach, not medical or dietary advice. Energy and nutrient needs vary widely by person, age, sex, and training load. Athletes with health concerns, a history of disordered eating, or anyone under 18 planning to change their weight should work with a physician and a registered dietitian.


Sources

About the author
David Brannan

Get new articles by email

Occasional notes on training, coaching and athletic performance. No daily noise.

Share this article