Skip to content
AthleticPeak Pro

Language

Text size

MenuMenu
Language

Text size

Start FreeSign in
Start Free
Back to journal
Methodology

Strength, Power, or Speed? Choosing the Right Training for Your Season

A coach’s guide to how Olympic lifting, powerlifting, bodybuilding, and CrossFit each fit into an athlete’s training year.

David Brannan Published Nov 14, 2026 14 min read
Strength, Power, or Speed? Choosing the Right Training for Your Season

My sophomore year at BYU, the athletic department opened a brand-new, $3 million weight room. It had every machine known to mankind. For a pole vaulter who loved to train, it was heaven.

I practically lived in that gym. Leg extensions, leg curls, chest machines, cable work: set after set of machine-based hypertrophy training. And it worked, sort of. I got bigger. I got stronger. I looked like an athlete who was doing everything right.

Then I'd go out to the runway, and my vaulting fell apart.

I was strong, but I was uncoordinated. I'd spent months training muscles in isolation, one joint at a time, sitting or lying on a pad while a machine guided the weight. Pole vaulting is the opposite. It's a sprint, a takeoff, a swing, and an inversion, with your whole body working together in a fraction of a second. My muscles had gotten bigger, but they'd forgotten how to work as a team.

Our strength and conditioning coach saw it. Instead of handing me a new machine routine, he sent me over to the throwers—the hammer, shot, and discus crew. They taught me the Olympic lifts: the snatch, the power clean, and the pulls. I spent the next few months training power with them.

The change was fast. Those lifts are whole-body movements, so you can't do them without coordination, timing, and speed. My coordination came back, and my base grew enormously. Before long I was vaulting on longer, stiffer poles with ease.



Freshman

Senior

100 meters

12.3 s

11.02 s

Vertical jump

28 in

34+ in

Poles

15'6" (4.75m)

16'10" (5.10m)

Same athlete. Same muscles. Different training.

I tell that story because every season I hear the same questions from athletes, parents, and coaches—and I see them argued endlessly online. Should I do Olympic lifts or powerlifting? Is CrossFit good for athletes? Should I lift heavy or light? Do I need to look like a bodybuilder?

Whether you’re a coach programming for a team or an individual athlete building your own year, the answer is the same: none of them is "best." Each one is a tool, and the athletes who improve the most use the right tool at the right time. My mistake at BYU wasn't lifting. It was doing one kind of lifting, for too long, with no plan for turning it into performance.

Let's break it down.

First, Remember What You're Training For

You are not a lifter. You're a sprinter, a jumper, a thrower, a vaulter, a forward, a linebacker. The weight room exists to make you better at your sport. That changes how you judge every program:

  • A lifter asks: "Did my total go up?"
  • An athlete asks: "Did I get faster, jump higher, throw farther, and stay healthy?"

Keep that second question in front of you as we go through each style.

Powerlifting: The Foundation of Force

What it is: Squat, bench press, deadlift. Heavy loads, low reps, long rest. The goal is maximal strength.

What it does for athletes: A lot, actually. Getting stronger in the legs carries over to speed. A 2014 meta-analysis in Sports Medicine (Seitz and colleagues) found a very strong relationship between how much athletes improved their back squat and how much their sprint times improved, with resistance training producing an average sprint improvement of about 3%. Three percent is a big deal on a track.

The catch: Heavy, slow strength is potential. Strength is the size of your engine, but sport is about how fast you can use it. A huge squat with no speed work behind it doesn't automatically become a fast 30 meters. And heavy grinding sets, especially taken to failure, leave you tired for days.

Best use: Building the base. Off-season and early pre-season, when you have time to recover and you're not trying to peak for a meet.

Olympic Lifting: Turning Strength into Power

What it is: The snatch and the clean and jerk, plus their "derivatives": hang cleans, power cleans, pulls, push jerks. These lifts force you to produce force fast, through a triple extension of the ankles, knees, and hips that looks a lot like jumping and sprinting.

What the research says: In a well-known 2004 study, Hoffman and colleagues split a college football team into an Olympic lifting group and a powerlifting group for 15 weeks. The Olympic lifting group improved their vertical jump significantly more. A larger 2021 meta-analysis of 34 studies found weightlifting training helped jump height, sprint times, and squat strength, and worked best when combined with traditional strength training, not as a replacement for it.

I didn't need a study to believe this. I lived it. When the throwers taught me to clean and snatch, I wasn't just getting stronger. I was learning to put strength from my feet, hips, and arms together in one explosive movement, which is exactly what a takeoff demands. There's a reason throwers have built their training around these lifts for decades.

The catch: The full lifts are technical. Plenty of coaches spend so much time teaching the catch that the athlete never gets enough load or speed to benefit. One 2022 study found that a technique-focused weightlifting program lost out to plain plyometrics for jumping and sprinting. The lesson: if your athlete can't do a clean well, use the simpler derivatives (pulls, hang high pulls, jump shrugs) or just jump.

Best use: The power phase. Late off-season and pre-season, after a strength base is built.

Bodybuilding: Building the Engine

What it is: Moderate weights, higher reps (roughly 8–15), lots of volume, and a focus on muscle size.

What it does for athletes: A bigger muscle has more potential to be a stronger muscle. Hypertrophy work also builds tendon and connective-tissue tolerance, fixes imbalances (think hamstrings, upper back, and the muscles around the hips and shoulders), and gives younger athletes a safe way to learn movement before loading heavy.

The catch: Size is only useful if your sport rewards it. A lineman or a thrower can use extra mass. A pole vaulter, high jumper, or distance runner has to carry every pound up and down the runway. And bodybuilding-style training to failure creates a lot of soreness, which is the last thing you want the week of a meet.

There's a second catch, and I learned it the hard way. Machine-based isolation work builds muscles one at a time, with the machine doing the balancing and the coordinating for you. Do only that for months, and you can end up like I did at BYU: bigger, stronger, and clumsier. Hypertrophy is a great base, but it's a base. It still has to be taught to move fast and as a whole.

Best use: General preparation at the start of the off-season, and as accessory work (single-leg, posterior chain, shoulder health) all year.

CrossFit: Fitness, Not Specificity

What it is: Constantly varied, high-intensity workouts mixing lifting, gymnastics, and conditioning, often for time.

What it does for athletes: It builds work capacity, toughness, and general conditioning, and it's fun. For a team, a CrossFit-style session can be a great general-prep or off-season conditioning day. That's exactly why we built the free Workout of the Day Roulette.

The catch: The biggest problem for athletes isn't safety. A 2022 systematic review found CrossFit's injury rate is similar to weightlifting and powerlifting, with the shoulder, spine, and knee most often hurt. The real problem is fatigue and specificity. Doing fast lifts tired and for reps trains you to move slowly under fatigue, which is the opposite of what a sprinter or jumper needs. Speed and power are trained fresh. Conditioning is trained tired. Mixing them every day blurs both.

Best use: General preparation, off-season conditioning, and team building. Keep it away from your speed and power days, and away from the competition season.

"Traditional" Athletic Training: The Blend

What most good strength coaches actually do is borrow from all of the above: a couple of big strength lifts, an Olympic derivative or jump, some single-leg and posterior-chain work, and plyometrics and sprints programmed alongside.

A typical session in this approach might look like:

  1. Warm-up and movement prep
  2. Short, high-quality sprint or plyometric work, done while fresh
  3. One primary strength or power lift (heavy squat, trap-bar deadlift, or power clean variation)
  4. One or two Olympic derivatives or loaded jumps
  5. Single-leg or posterior-chain accessory work

A 2025 network meta-analysis comparing traditional strength training, weightlifting, and plyometrics found no clear overall winner:

Method

Looked best for

Traditional strength training

Maximal strength

Weightlifting

Sprinting

Plyometrics

Countermovement jumps

That's the whole point: different tools, different jobs. The traditional blend simply puts the right tool in the right place inside the same session or week.

The Styles at a Glance

Style

What it builds

The catch

Best use

Powerlifting

Maximal strength: the engine

Slow strength doesn't automatically become speed; grinding sets leave you tired

Off-season and early pre-season base

Olympic lifting

Power: firing the engine fast

Technical; too much time teaching the catch

Power phase, after a strength base

Bodybuilding

Muscle, tendon tolerance, balance

Extra mass to carry; soreness; isolation can cost coordination

General prep and year-round accessory work

CrossFit

Work capacity, toughness, conditioning

Fatigue blurs speed and power

General prep, off-season conditioning, team building

Traditional blend

A bit of everything

Needs a plan to put it together

Most of the year, phased

Heavy vs. Light: What's the Difference?

Think of strength as a line running from heavy and slow to light and fast:

Load

Example

What it develops

Very heavy (85–100% of max)

Heavy squats, deadlifts

Maximal strength: the size of the engine

Moderate-heavy (60–80%)

Power cleans, speed squats

Strength-speed: moving heavy things fast

Light (30–60%)

Jump squats, trap-bar jumps, medicine-ball throws

Speed-strength: moving light things very fast

Body weight or less

Plyometrics, sprints, bounds

Pure speed and elasticity

Training adapts to the speed you train at. A classic 2002 study found that athletes doing light jump squats (30% of their max) gained the most in movement velocity, while heavy loads build force. Neither is wrong. An athlete needs both ends of the line.

Two practical rules:

  1. Stop sets before they turn into grinders. Research on velocity-based training found that cutting a set when bar speed drops about 10% hurt sprint and jump performance much less, immediately and the next day, than going to failure, even with the same load and volume. For athletes, quality reps beat exhausted reps.
  2. Weaker athletes should get strong first. If an athlete can't squat about their body weight with good form, heavy-ish strength work is the fastest route to faster sprints. Once they're strong, the gains come from the fast end of the line.

There's an old saying coaches use that sums this up better than any study:

If you are weak and slow, focus on strength. If you are slow but strong, focus on power. If you are strong and powerful, focus on speed.

It works because it starts with the athlete, not the program:

Athlete

Where to spend the next block

A freshman who can't squat their body weight

Heavy strength work

A strong senior whose jumps and sprints haven't improved

Olympic derivatives and loaded jumps, to turn that strength into power

An athlete who is already strong and explosive

The light, fast end of the line: sprints, plyometrics, and competition-speed work

Test where your athlete is (a squat or trap-bar max, a vertical or broad jump, a timed 30 meters) and the saying tells you where to spend the next training block. Our free 1RM estimator, relative strength calculator, and benchmark comparison can help you figure out which line describes your athlete.

Looking back, my sophomore year was a textbook case of the second line. Months of machine work had made me strong, but I was still slow and uncoordinated. More strength wasn't the answer. Power was. The moment my training shifted to it, my times and my vaulting followed.

Putting It Together: The Season Plan

Here's how I'd lay it out across a year for a sprinter, jumper, or most power athletes. You can map these same phases around your meet and game dates in our free Season Planner:

Phase

Main focus

Style it borrows from

Loads

General prep (early off-season, 4–8 weeks)

Muscle, tendon, work capacity, fix weaknesses

Bodybuilding + CrossFit-style conditioning

Moderate, higher reps

Max strength (mid off-season, 4–8 weeks)

Build the engine

Powerlifting

Heavy, low reps

Power conversion (pre-season, 4–6 weeks)

Turn strength into speed

Olympic derivatives + jumps + sprints

Moderate to light, fast

In-season (competition)

Keep strength and power, stay fresh

Short, crisp "traditional" sessions

Heavy-ish but low volume; never to failure

Peak/taper (championship weeks)

Be as fast as you've ever been

Mostly speed and plyometrics

Light, very low volume

The biggest mistake I see is an athlete who does the same program in October and in May. If you only take one thing from this article, take that.

How AthleticPeak Pro Fits In

We built AthleticPeak Pro for athletes and coaches, not lifters, and these are the tools we use to plan exactly this kind of year. Start with the Season Planner: lay out your phases first, then pick the tools for each one.

  • Season Planner (free): Lay out your phases, from general prep to max strength, power, in-season, and peak, then print the season plan.
  • Athletics programs: Prepare, Build, and Sharpen. Three track-and-field programs that follow the phases in this article.

Program

Length

Focus

Prepare

8 weeks

General capacity, movement quality, and a strength foundation

Build

12 weeks

Strength, power, sprint quality, and event practice

Sharpen

12 weeks

Speed, power, and event work, with low-volume strength maintenance as competition approaches

  • Barbell programs: For a dedicated max-strength block, use the barbell programs in the library. They're there on purpose: sprinters, jumpers, and throwers rely on heavy strength.
  • Guided Workout Builder (free): Build acceleration, maximum-speed, speed-endurance, strength, and recovery sessions across four season phases, then export them to your Training Plan.
  • Week Balance Planner (free): See how your weekly sets cover each muscle. It's a good check during a hypertrophy block, so you don't end up in the isolation trap I fell into.
  • Workout of the Day Roulette and Bodyweight Roulette (free): General-prep conditioning and off-season variety without turning every day into a grind.
  • Workout logger and the coaching workspace: The only way to know whether your strength block actually made you faster is to record it. Athletes train free, and their training record follows them from team to team.

See all of our free training tools.

The coach still makes the decisions. AthleticPeak gives you the tools and the record.

The Bottom Line

  • Powerlifting builds the engine.
  • Olympic lifting teaches the engine to fire fast.
  • Bodybuilding builds the chassis and keeps it healthy.
  • CrossFit builds general fitness and toughness.
  • Heavy loads build force; light loads build speed. Athletes need both.
  • The plan matters more than the style. Put the right tool in the right phase.

That $3 million weight room didn't make me a better vaulter. A plan did, along with a coach who noticed what I needed and a group of throwers willing to teach a vaulter how to clean. So stop arguing about which style is best, and start planning which style belongs in which month.

References

  1. Seitz LB, et al. (2014). Increases in lower-body strength transfer positively to sprint performance: a systematic review with meta-analysis. Sports Medicine, 44(12), 1693–1702. PubMed
  2. Hoffman JR, Cooper J, Wendell M, Kang J. (2004). Comparison of Olympic vs. traditional power lifting training programs in football players. J Strength Cond Res, 18(1), 129–135. Journal (DOI)
  3. Meta-analysis of weightlifting training on jump, sprint, and squat strength (34 studies, 2021). Int J Sports Sci Coach. SAGE Journals
  4. Berton R, et al. (2022). Weightlifting derivatives vs. plyometric exercises: effects on unloaded and loaded vertical jumps and sprint performance. PLoS ONE. PLoS ONE
  5. Wang S, Zhen J, Xiao T. (2025). Effects of three strength training methods on lower extremity strength, jump and sprint performance: a network meta-analysis. Frontiers in Physiology. Frontiers
  6. McBride JM, et al. (2002). The effect of heavy- vs. light-load jump squats on the development of strength, power, and speed. J Strength Cond Res, 16(1), 75–82. PubMed
  7. Jump and sprint performance directly and 24 h after velocity- vs. failure-based training (2022). Int J Sports Med. Thieme
  8. Injury in CrossFit: a systematic review of epidemiology and risk factors (2022). Phys Sportsmed, 50(1), 3–10. PubMed
About the author
David Brannan

Get new articles by email

Occasional notes on training, coaching and athletic performance. No daily noise.

Share this article